Where do markings go if you change filenames?
Hi - I would love a better understanding of how Piascore stores markings. It seems like the markings are tied to the actual filename of the PDF on your device. But if that's true, I have some questions:
- If I change the filename of a PDF score on my device, my markings disappear. Do I have to change the filename back to its original name to see the markings again? If I can't remember the original filename, are the markings lost forever?
- What happens if I replace a marked score with another file with the same filename? Will the markings show up on the new file, even if the score is completely different?
- Is there a way to save a marked score to a different device so that I can make more edits? I only see the method of saving a marked score as a new PDF where the markings are permanent in the new PDF.
Thanks!
-
Offizieller Kommentar
Hi,
Thank you for the detailed questions.
You are right that markings are tied to the PDF file.1. Renaming a file
Piascore manages scores by the filename of the PDF.
When you rename a file, Piascore treats it as a different score, and the markings and metadata that belonged to the old filename are most likely deleted at that point.
Renaming the file back to its original name will therefore not reliably bring the markings back.
If you have a backup of your device from before the rename, restoring from that backup is the only way to recover them.
Without a backup, the markings cannot be recovered.2. Replacing a marked score with a different file under the same filename
The markings are held against the filename, so they will be shown on the new file.
Even if the music is completely different, the old markings will appear on top of the new score, in the same positions.
We would recommend giving the new file its own filename instead.3. Moving a marked score to another device, with the markings still editable
We are sorry, but this is not possible at the moment.
Piascore does not sync between devices, and the only per-score export is a PDF with the markings merged into it, as you found.
The one way to carry editable markings across is to restore a full device backup onto the other device, which replaces everything on that device, so it is not practical for a single score.
We would like to support this, and we will consider it for a future version.* FAQ : How to back up
https://help.piascore.com/hc/articles/360000877732One suggestion in the meantime.
Because the markings are tied to the filename, it is worth settling on a filename before you start marking a score, and keeping a backup of your device.Thank you for taking the time to write.
-
Thanks for these answers. It is helpful to understand better how the app works so that I can be careful not to lose my markings.
One more question: If I move a file to another folder inside the Piascore folder (e.g., “archive”), and then I move it back to the main Piascore folder, I see that the markings are still there. How long will the Piascore app remember markings for a file if that file has been moved outside the Piascore folder?
One feature request: When using the “Sharing/printing file” command to make a “Copy in the app”, could you allow the filename to be changed before the copy is made? The filename automatically created by Piascore can be very long/complex, and it would be nice to have the option to edit the filename of the new copy before it is set by Piascore.
Thank you!
0
Bitte melden Sie sich an, um einen Kommentar zu hinterlassen.
Kommentare
2 Kommentare